Aftershocks from Global Carry Trade: What's Next?
The reverberations of a massive carry trade have rattled global financial markets. Investors brace for more volatility ahead as key market indices experience turbulence.
Published August 07, 2024 - 00:08am
New York: Investors indicated that the aftershocks of a massive carry trade that has trembled through global financial markets were far from over. The unwinding process, still in its nascent stage, promises potential shake-outs to other assets in the forthcoming days.
Recent market developments illustrated this volatility. The Nasdaq Composite and the S&P 500 trimmed their losses by close on Monday, concluding a grueling three-day selloff. Similarly, Tokyo markets rebounded following a comparable rout in Tuesday trading. These selloffs were precipitated by a higher-than-expected U.S. unemployment rate on Friday, rekindling fears of an impending recession. The market concerns intensified as investors began winding down yen-funded trades—financial maneuvers that have underpinned stock acquisitions for years—prompted by an unexpected Bank of Japan rate hike last week.
The term 'carry trade' is commonplace in currency markets. It involves borrowing money from economies with low-interest rates, such as Japan or Switzerland, to finance investments in higher-yielding assets elsewhere, in this instance, stocks. Although the recent sell-off showed signs of easing, investors remained apprehensive about more turbulence ahead. Zhe Shen, head of diversifying strategies at TIFF Investment Management, noted, We expect the sell-off to continue for maybe a few more days as usually these ... trades are pretty large. Shen explained that many traders opted to delay further sell-offs to limit immediate losses.
Highlighting the magnitude of the yen carry trades, Ulf Lindahl, CEO at Currency Research Associates, expressed, There's tons and tons of yen carry trades that still have to be closed out. Investors are yet grappling to ascertain the scale of these trades and the extent of cheap funding deployed in equities. Estimates by hedge fund research firm PivotalPath reveal that hedge fund strategies most impacted by a yen rally are global macro, quantitative, and managed futures due to their short positions in yen.
Further compounding these market anxieties are analyses from Kathy Jones, chief fixed income strategist at Schwab, who stated, It's very, very hard to know the actual size of those positions and how much is hedged and how much isn't, and therefore how much pressure is on. When leveraged hedge funds with derivatives encounter volatile markets, sizable reactions ensue, as exemplified by the recent market events.
Several money managers and trading strategies had preemptively begun reducing their risk exposure in recent days. Mike Gleason, director of equity alternative strategies at Acadian, observed, Momentum certainly has been unwinding quite a bit in the past few days, and that's cutting across all asset classes. This simultaneous response among various asset classes has further exacerbated market volatility.
IBKR Securities Services' head trader, Steve Sosnick, characterized the recent trading conditions as having a forced selling nature. There was a certain 'get me out' quality to the pre-market and opening trades that since have subsided, he observed.
Hedge funds had already started unwinding their risk positions roughly two weeks ago when stocks began to decline. Morgan Stanley's June 25 estimate indicated that macro hedge funds might offload up to $110 billion if market conditions continued to deteriorate. Yet for some investors, a Nasdaq fall of 10% below its record points signified another barrier to a quick recovery.
Lindahl warned, Most of the people haven't unwound anything yet because they think it's just a regular correction. But he emphasized the gravity of the situation, explaining that major indexes don't typically experience 4-5% gap openings and then recover, predicting, There's a serious collapse that's coming.
On the horizon, fluctuations in U.S. index futures indicate that some investors are looking to buy at lower valuations, hinting at a potentially two-way market. Similarly, forecasts by Schwab suggest a fair number of traders are prepared to capitalize on recent downturns.
The enduring market volatility serves as a potent reminder of the complexities within global financial systems. The extensive reliance on yen carry trades reveals the interconnectedness and fragility of global economies. As investors and analysts continue to grapple with market uncertainties, they remain vigilant of broader economic implications and potential policy shifts worldwide.